-
10 Most overrated Drummers of all time
I don't know who Reuben Levy is but I guess everyone is entitled to their opinions. This list will definitely stir up some feelings...LOL...I never rag on other drummers because it is not a competition in my opinion but I do agree with most of this list less the harsh words and Steve Gadd. Steve Gadd overrated ??Really?? Different strokes I guess!
Check it out.
https://thezreview.com/2017/07/24/to...drummers-time/
-
Re: 10 Most overrated Drummers of all time
The author is a self-professed provocateur. A child can do it. Pay no mind.
-
Re: 10 Most overrated Drummers of all time
Actually I would only debate him on 1. Steve Gadd. The rest I pretty much agree with him on.
-
Re: 10 Most overrated Drummers of all time
Wow. Just wow. Somehow, I don't think Max, Charlie, Hal or Ginger (or any of them for that matter) give a rip who thinks they're over-rated. They're too busy enjoying the fruits of their labor.
I can see where Max, Charlie & Ginger could be considered "lucky". We're it not for their respective bands and the success of the band as a whole, we may never have heard of them. I think Hal has established himself on his own.
-
Re: 10 Most overrated Drummers of all time
These lists are always interesting. I never heard of this journalist either but he was pretty harsh but comical. I want to know his 10 most underated drummers.
-
Re: 10 Most overrated Drummers of all time
Somehow I knew before going there that Lars would make the list ...
-
Re: 10 Most overrated Drummers of all time
Quote:
Originally Posted by
dangermoney
Somehow I knew before going there that Lars would make the list ...
LOL ... of course!
-
Re: 10 Most overrated Drummers of all time
Quote:
Originally Posted by
dangermoney
Somehow I knew before going there that Lars would make the list ...
Yep...Lars, Tommy Lee and Kieth Moon. Those guys alway get dogged on.
I too would like to see his "under-rated" drummer list. OR....his over-rated guitar players list.
-
Re: 10 Most overrated Drummers of all time
All drummers are kinda over rated. After all, all we do is beat on things for the amusement of others.
LOL
all the best...
-
Re: 10 Most overrated Drummers of all time
Quote:
Originally Posted by
rickthedrummer
Actually I would only debate him on 1. Steve Gadd. The rest I pretty much agree with him on.
I also am glad I wasn't the only one!
-
Re: 10 Most overrated Drummers of all time
Quote:
Originally Posted by
dangermoney
Somehow I knew before going there that Lars would make the list ...
It's obvious why......
-
Re: 10 Most overrated Drummers of all time
Moon, and for that matter, the entire membership of The Who, drive me nuts with their work:
Moments of remarkable brilliance -- but for the most part nothing special.
Moon was most definitely unique in his approach -- and -- when he was not completely chemically wasted, could actually lay down decent tracks in the studio.
As you watch video of him and The Who, you will rarely see him use a high hat.
-
Re: 10 Most overrated Drummers of all time
Well, at least none of us made the list. That's a good thing! :icon_lol:
-
Re: 10 Most overrated Drummers of all time
Quote:
Originally Posted by
DrumWhipper
Well, at least none of us made the list. That's a good thing! :icon_lol:
Well....unless Drummer is actually one of the 10 on the list. I suppose it's safe to assume he's not Keith Moon. Hmmmm....
-
Re: 10 Most overrated Drummers of all time
I'd remove Keith Moon and add Mick Fleetwood.
-
Re: 10 Most overrated Drummers of all time
What no Neil Peart or Bonzo but Tommy Lee is on the list. Something wrong there lol
-
1 Attachment(s)
Re: 10 Most overrated Drummers of all time
Quote:
Originally Posted by
N2Bluz
Well....unless Drummer is actually one of the 10 on the list. I suppose it's safe to assume he's not Keith Moon. Hmmmm....
Attachment 14045
This is Tom in his disguise. Never would have guessed. I thought maybe he was ?love.
-
Re: 10 Most overrated Drummers of all time
Quote:
Originally Posted by
rickthedrummer
Attachment 14045
This is Tom in his disguise. Never would have guessed. I thought maybe he was ?love.
That's quite a close resemblance. :loller4:
-
Re: 10 Most overrated Drummers of all time
Quote:
Originally Posted by
drummer
That's quite a close resemblance. :loller4:
Hey Tom, I remember when you were a black guy, so it stands to reason that you can morph into anyone you want, and who wouldn't want Hannah Ford?????
-
Re: 10 Most overrated Drummers of all time
Except for Gadd, pretty accurate IMHO. I'd add a few others as well.
-
Re: 10 Most overrated Drummers of all time
Quote:
Originally Posted by
inthpktplayer
Except for Gadd, pretty accurate IMHO. I'd add a few others as well.
I agree, I would remove Gadd from list, Move Moon up to #1 and I would probably ad Carmine Appice to the list.
-
Re: 10 Most overrated Drummers of all time
-
Re: 10 Most overrated Drummers of all time
the most retarded list i have seen
-
1 Attachment(s)
Re: 10 Most overrated Drummers of all time
Quote:
Originally Posted by
drummer
That's quite a close resemblance. :loller4:
Hmmm. Long hair...makeup....I KNEW it!!!
Attachment 14048
-
Re: 10 Most overrated Drummers of all time
Quote:
Originally Posted by
rickthedrummer
Hey Tom, I remember when you were a black guy, so it stands to reason that you can morph into anyone you want, and who wouldn't want Hannah Ford?????
Ha-ha! You know me all too well Rick! :icon_mrgreen: