Sorry to ask this question, I'm sure it has been asked.
I would like to know whether playing heel down, when mastered, is faster or more consistent than playing heel up. From experience, I know that when playing heel down, it is harder to get a nice punch because of the lack of power.
Yes, there will be exceptions and I'm sure it depends on the style, height of the drummer, bla bla, etc. But in general, if I were to choose one, would it be more beneficial to play heel down?
Thanks
You've kind of answered your own question. It honestly depends on the player on how they develop their technique. I play heel down 95% of the time. I only play heel up when I get it into my head that I want to get comfortable with it in order to be more versatile. Honestly, though, it's like the argument between match and traditional grip. You can do the same things with both styles if you master them so it ultimately doesn't matter. Just go with what you like.
^^^ SGD's Evans Empire ^^^
And I am of the opposite school and play heel-up 99% of the time.
When I started playing drums I was 8 and sharing my 14 year old brothers kit, so I could only reach the pedals with my toes! Never have gotten comfortable with heel down at all.
I do get some nice comments on my technique as a single pedal player, though.
Match grip, too, just to put it out there.
Just play and see what comes naturally and build from there. Just my 2 cents.
Proudly playing:
Doc Sweeney Drums
A bunch of snares
A bunch of cymbals
Off-Set double pedals
I think I love to play the drums simply because you get to hit 'em!!!
Heel up is generally regarded as the position to play faster more powerful strokes. I play heel up just because its easier and feels more comfortable... These things its mostly just personal preference though
Currently: Black Pearl Export Signature 8-Piece
22" Bass Drum x2
10" Rack Tom
12" Rack Tom
13" Rack Tom
14" Floor Tom
16" Floor Tom
13" Sig Snare
Paiste Cymbals
Alpha 14" Hats
Alpha 17" Rock Crash
Alpha 19" Rock Crash
Alpha 20" Metal Ride
Alpha 18" China
Zildjian 22" Amir Medium Impulse Ride (1980s)
Cajon
Meinl Makah Burl
i like people to hear the bass drum, heel up FTW
It also depends on how you are seated behind the drums. I found of I lean back a little then the heel up is more comfortable and louder but for most part I play heel down for soft to mid hitting. Once in a while I will lean back and give her a couple of good whacks where it is needed.
I play heel up, all the time. Wish I could play heel down well, but I don't get enough power and I find that my shins hurt after a short time!
"We make a living by what we get, but we make a life by what we give." - Winston Churchill
See, it's all subjective. I feel like I can get the same power out of heel down as I can heel up (excluding taking my foot completely off the pedal and stomping down). But I know that most seem to find heel up more comfortable. I remember my drum teacher giving me a weird look when I told him I preferred heel down. His words: "that's a first". LOL!
^^^ SGD's Evans Empire ^^^
Welcome to the board Nehalem, you did kind of answer your own question but it is one of those personal things.Its what is most comfortable to you that really matters.
I play both ways depending on what and how Im playing, most of the time its heel up. This is where you will see more power / speed.
slot # 1
In support of l e i g h ' s campaign..............DC Record for Most Users Online
BE COUNTED! http://www.drumchat.com/showthread.php/dc-record-most-users-12079p2.html
CHARTER MEMBER OF PHROGGE'S AQUARIAN ARMY
The Zildjian League
Zildjian Vintage A Team
RIP Frank.............thanks for being part of my journey
Well, thanks for the comments. I suppose bottom line is: if you would have to choose one style, based on whether it would be more advantageous than the other, which would you choose? Just out of interest.
Heel up for me dude, but that's mainly because i can't play heel down to save myself.
I play heel down when we're playing our acoustic song so it's not as punchy and powerful, otherwise it's heel up.
i play mainly heels down for double pedal i dont know why but if i try to play double pedal with heels up i end up out of time with my feet :/ need to practice it :/ but it may be because im 6 foot four and its more comfy to have my feet flat on the ground :D
| Yamaha Stage Custom | Sabian AAX | Dream |
I play heel up for power and heel down when I am trying to feather the bass drum or when I need to play at a low volume and I use them interchangeably and I don't even notice I guess it is subconcious depending what I am trying to achieve musically.
I use heel up for my bass drum pedals, and heel down for my hi-hats.
-Reuben
SABIAN SQUAD
^^^SGD'S EVANS EMPIRE^^^
RIP Frank "Fiacovaz" Iacovazzi
I only do heel down when I'm doing single bass drum triplets, and only then because I start in heel up and have to somehow do a moeller movement with my feet to get all three hits. The joys of being small.
Today, on Ethel The Frog...
Both, Up for a harder punchier sounding hit and down for more deep sustaining boom.
I go up. I get some sort of bounce when I do down. And the bass is heard more
PHROGGE'S AQUARIAN ARMY
TERROROUS TENORS
TAMAHOLIC
RIP frank. You'll never be forgotten.
Post by Yohin: "I never say anything good enough for anyone's sig."
I only use heel down when I'm playing jazz and feathering the bass drum. Otherwise I use heel up for everything else, because there's more power, speed, control, just that I find it easier to tap the bass drum head lightly when using heel down.
- Zack
should be able to do both..
Heel up,or down. That is the question. Whether tis nobler to suffer the shin splints
of a flat foot on the pedel, or to let the blood flow to the muscles needed to punch it out! I`ve found flat foot fatigues my leg faster. 45 to 60 min. sets, takes its toll early on. I sit w/ thighs horizontal, leavel to the snare. I`ve found that resting on the ball of UR foot, U still have soft control & full power to blast out a PILE DRIVIN KICK !!!
Hence the term....."KICK DRUM !!!" BUT...what ever works best for you.
" Dont Stop Believin!"
Bookmarks